Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
#11
Re: Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
Wow, nice. Yeah this is more a modern lighting treatment. Are you using the Tezro for rendering?

Octane 2x400O2 300O2 400Origin 200 2x250
Intuition
Octane

Posts: 99
Threads: 13
Joined: Dec 2017
Find Reply
06-28-2018, 03:53 AM
#12
Re: Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
Intuition post_id=1228 time=1530157992 user_id=55 Wrote:Wow, nice. Yeah this is more a modern lighting treatment. Are you using the Tezro for rendering?

I am.

I will post the rendering using 8 rays later, it took just over an hour to render this morning before I went to work!

The image with 8 rays:



   

It's slightly better than the one with 3 rays from a noise point of view, but still needs work in my opinion.

[Image: rZbyrYx.png]
Irinikus
Connoisseur

Posts: 559
Threads: 76
Joined: Dec 2017
Website Find Reply
06-28-2018, 08:37 AM
#13
Re: Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
Now here's a Tezro working at full throttle! (There's absolutely nothing to spare!)


   


I'm now rendering at 8x sampling with a penumbra of 10 with 16 rays with a max ray depth of 8 and a light diameter of 0.2 with linear decay and an intensity of 10

[Image: rZbyrYx.png]
Irinikus
Connoisseur

Posts: 559
Threads: 76
Joined: Dec 2017
Website Find Reply
06-28-2018, 01:52 PM
#14
Re: Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
Hmm, an hour? Seems long for Tezro.

I don't have my SGI with me right now as I am doing wood work for a while. I feel like it should be 10 minutes at the most on a Tezro. But I often test with one light and maybe two or three raytraced lights are adding up quickly. If I had the Octane here I could test the render time. Maybe some optimizations can be made.

Looking nice tho

Octane 2x400O2 300O2 400Origin 200 2x250
Intuition
Octane

Posts: 99
Threads: 13
Joined: Dec 2017
Find Reply
06-28-2018, 03:12 PM
#15
Re: Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
Intuition post_id=1242 time=1530198771 user_id=55 Wrote:Hmm, an hour? Seems long for Tezro.

I don't have my SGI with me right now as I am doing wood work for a while. I feel like it should be 10 minutes at the most on a Tezro. But I often test with one light and maybe two or three raytraced lights are adding up quickly. If I had the Octane here I could test the render time. Maybe some optimizations can be made.

Looking nice tho

You can see from the image that I posted up above, that it uses every ounce of the Tezro's CPU capability. (4x 1GHz with 16MB of "slow" cache per CPU!)

My current current rendering has probably been going for close to two hours and is only 3 quarters rendered!

I found in the past, that this happens with 3D Studio Max as well, often your rendering options can cause a model to take forever to render with little to no improvement to overall quality.

Here are the images together to allow for a qualitative comparison:


Shadow map:
   


Raytraced with decay set to linear, 2 rays with 8X sampling:
   


Raytraced with penumbra set to 10, light diameter set to 1, decay set to linear, 3 rays with 8X sampling:
   


Raytraced with penumbra set to 10, light diameter set to 1, decay set to linear, 8 rays with 8X sampling:
   


Raytraced with penumbra set to 10, light diameter set to 0.2, decay set to linear, 16 rays with a max ray depth of 8 with 8X sampling:
   


Something that I've observed is that there is a loss of image quality when the images are saved as Jpegs!

[Image: rZbyrYx.png]
Irinikus
Connoisseur

Posts: 559
Threads: 76
Joined: Dec 2017
Website Find Reply
06-28-2018, 03:52 PM
#16
Re: Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
Yeah it seems too long. I don't think my Octane would be that long to render that. I know Maya software is unforgiving with multiple lights though. You may want to try mental ray. It may be ooodles faster with 4 cpus but you'll need to set it up. I forget the old Maya software is painfully slow. BUT it still seems excessive especially on a Tezro with 4 cpus.

Mental Ray can uses same shaders / lights Maya software does

Then set

custom adaptive sampling min -1 max 1
triangle filter
anti-aliasing contrast ratio 0.25 to start.

Looking good though, but does seem too long for a Tezro. You aren't even using GI yet. I have had GI and multiple lights on my o2 not take an hour with soft shadows. You do have a complex item though, most of my test renders on SGI have been simple shapes except the displacement scene I had on Neko.

Octane 2x400O2 300O2 400Origin 200 2x250
Intuition
Octane

Posts: 99
Threads: 13
Joined: Dec 2017
Find Reply
06-28-2018, 04:28 PM
#17
Re: Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
Intuition post_id=1245 time=1530203337 user_id=55 Wrote:Yeah it seems too long. I don't think my Octane would be that long to render that. I know Maya software is unforgiving with multiple lights though. You may want to try mental ray. It may be ooodles faster with 4 cpus but you'll need to set it up. I forget the old Maya software is painfully slow. BUT it still seems excessive especially on a Tezro with 4 cpus.

Mental Ray can uses same shaders / lights Maya software does

Then set

custom adaptive sampling min -1 max 1
triangle filter
anti-aliasing contrast ratio 0.25 to start.

Looking good though, but does seem too long for a Tezro. You aren't even using GI yet. I have had GI and multiple lights on my o2 not take an hour with soft shadows. You do have a complex item though, most of my test renders on SGI have been simple shapes except the displacement scene I had on Neko.

The latest rendition is still rendering, so I can't access the menus right now, just one question, can't you use an adaptive filter in Maya software?

In 3D Studio Max, I used to make use of their fast adaptive filter, and it worked wonders!

[Image: rZbyrYx.png]
Irinikus
Connoisseur

Posts: 559
Threads: 76
Joined: Dec 2017
Website Find Reply
06-28-2018, 04:37 PM
#18
Re: Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
I've solved the problem, rendering to Jpeg gave a crappy output!

This image was rendered with 3 rays and took jus over 10 min to render!


   

[Image: rZbyrYx.png]
Irinikus
Connoisseur

Posts: 559
Threads: 76
Joined: Dec 2017
Website Find Reply
06-28-2018, 05:44 PM
#19
Re: Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
Yeah that is the "custom" adaptive sampling and filters. It is how you can set the min max if I remember. I don't have it in front of me in SGI. Only modern Mayas 2016-2018.

I set the pixel filter to Triangle for sharpness. Or Guassian for smoothness

But, I can't remember if that is a Mental Ray feature or 3dsmax specific. I've used Mental Ray in Softimage, Maya, and Max and know that there are a few little options specific to each package. The filter should be in all three though.

EDIT----

Yeah ten minutes seems right for that. Big Grin

OH, I just thought the original render was smooth and it was compressed for upload. Yes. jpg native gives compressed results.

Octane 2x400O2 300O2 400Origin 200 2x250
Intuition
Octane

Posts: 99
Threads: 13
Joined: Dec 2017
Find Reply
06-28-2018, 05:51 PM
#20
Re: Rendering in Maya 6.5 (A simple speaker drive unit.)
Intuition post_id=1250 time=1530208299 user_id=55 Wrote:Yeah that is the "custom" adaptive sampling and filters. It is how you can set the min max if I remember. I don't have it in front of me in SGI. Only modern Mayas 2016-2018.

I set the pixel filter to Triangle for sharpness. Or Guassian for smoothness

But, I can't remember if that is a Mental Ray feature or 3dsmax specific. I've used Mental Ray in Softimage, Maya, and Max and know that there are a few little options specific to each package. The filter should be in all three though.

EDIT----

Yeah ten minutes seems right for that. Big Grin

OH, I just thought the original render was smooth and it was compressed for upload. Yes. jpg native gives compressed results.

Thanks very much for the pointers, as they've really helped so far! Smile

[Image: rZbyrYx.png]
Irinikus
Connoisseur

Posts: 559
Threads: 76
Joined: Dec 2017
Website Find Reply
06-28-2018, 05:55 PM


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)